Guide For Fort Worth, Texas Truck Accident Cases

semi truck on highwayDrivers and pedestrians are no match for an oncoming 18 wheeler. When a semi-truck causes an accident then the victim or victims are likely to suffer serious injuries or even a wrongful death. What makes matters worse is that such cases tend to be far more complicated than a typical car accident. This is due to the fact that these types of cases often involve multiple defendants and often involve expert witnesses, in addition to a victim having suffered serious harm. The complicated nature of these types of cases can result in a victim or their families not knowing what steps to take next. It is important to take immediate action, however, so that one’s rights are fully protected. Accordingly, Noteboom – The Law Firm is providing this informational guide out of the hope that the victims of such injuries can better understand the nature of their situation. If you or a loved one need assistance, then contact our office today to speak with a DFW truck accident lawyer.

Contact Us

As with our guide on handling wrongful death matters, this article is meant to serve as an overview of how Texas law applies to trucking accidents. To view a particular section of this guide, simply click “jump to section” in the table of contents below.

Table of Contents

  • Who are the defendants in a Texas truck accident case? (jump to section)
  • Calculating damages in a DFW truck accident case (jump to section)
    • A truck accident victim may be entitled to compensatory damages (jump to section)
    • Punitive damages will rarely (but sometimes) be awarded in a trucking accident case (jump to section)
    • Texas’ comparative fault laws will apply to trucking accidents in Fort Worth and elsewhere (jump to section)
    • How Texas’ joint and several liability standards apply in truck accident cases involving multiple defendants (jump to section)
  • The stages of handling personal injury claims stemming from truck accidents in Fort Worth and other Texas areas (jump to section)
    • Truck accident cases will largely be in a “holding pattern” while the victim treats for their injuries and may take some time to settle (jump to section)
    • The negotiation phase of a case will begin with the sending of a demand letter (jump to section)
    • The litigation phase of a truck accident case (jump to section)
  • Selecting a lawyer for truck accident cases in Fort Worth or other parts of Texas (jump to section)

Who are the defendants in a Texas truck accident case?

(back to contents)

gavel stacked on law booksIt is vital that all defendants in any personal injury case be identified. This is equally true in matters involving an 18-wheeler, as failing to name a possible defendant can result in a victim not receiving the full amount of compensation to which they are entitled. With that said, the range of possible defendants in such matters can vary greatly. Some cases may only involve a single defendant (the owner-operator of the truck) while others may involve numerous parties. This section of our guide will discuss each of these issues in turn.

It is vital that all defendants in a trucking accident case be identified

(back to contents)

If multiple parties are potentially liable for a trucking accident, then it is vital that each one be identified and named in any potential lawsuit. There are several reasons for this. First, as will be discussed more in depth below in this guide’s section on Joint & Several Liability, each defendant may not be required to pay an amount greater than their share of fault for an accident. This can mean that one will only receive a judgment for a portion of their actual damages. Moreover, cases which involve multiple defendants can mean that several different insurance carriers will be involved in the case. The amount of coverage available to each defendant may vary, and by naming all possible parties, one helps to ensure that they can collect as much of their damages as possible. Finally, there may be instances in which one defendant may actually help the Plaintiff’s case by demonstrating that a defendant other than themselves was responsible for the wreck. These are just some of the reasons why one of the first steps towards getting a case off on the right foot is to name all possible defendants.

Trucking accident cases may effectively only involve a single defendant

(back to contents)

Many semi-trucks on the road are “owner-operated.” By this we mean that the driver of the vehicle is also the sole owner (although he or she will often form an LLC or other company to operate the business). In these types of cases, the owner-operator may be the only defendant. If they have formed a separate company, then both the owner and the company will be named as defendants. In such matters, the issue of which party bears more of the fault for the wreck is greatly simplified. Other additional defendants may include third-parties not related to the ownership or management of the truck itself (more on this below).

Trucking accident cases may involve multiple defendants

(back to contents)

A number of trucking accident cases may involve multiple defendants if the driver was operating as an employee or independent contractor of the owner. Potential defendants in such matters may include the following:

The truck driver

(back to contents)

If the truck driver’s negligence caused or partially caused the accident then, for obvious reasons, they may face liability. While such drivers are typically hourly employees or salaried individuals, the truck owner’s insurance policy will typically apply to their actions.

The owner or ownership company of the truck

(back to contents)

man on witness standIf the owner of the truck is the employer of the driver, then they will be vicariously liable for their employee’s actions. In other words, an employer is liable for the action of their employees. This is true whether the owner of the truck is another individual, a corporation, an LLC, or some other legal entity. In addition to being liable for any damages caused by the driver, additional theories of liability may apply to the owner. If, for example, it is shown that the owner of the vehicle failed to adequately screen or supervise the driver, then the owner may also face liability for negligent hiring and supervision. This is just one example of how additional theories of liability may apply to an owner.

There may be instances in which the owner of the vehicle is neither the operator of the truck nor the employer of the driver. If the owner or owning company uses a third-party management company to manage the truck (which would include hiring employees), then the owner may still face liability if it is shown that their own negligence somehow contributed to the accident. The extent to which liability will attach directly to the truck’s owners in such situations will always depend on the specifics of the matter. One fact that will often establish liability is that if the owner knew, or should have known, that the management company was negligently performing its duties and took no action. While the facts of each case will vary, it would be rare for the truck’s owner or ownership company to not be named in a lawsuit.

Third-party management companies may be liable for a truck accident

(back to contents)

As mentioned above, the owners of semi-trucks sometimes utilize third-party management companies to manage the day-to-day operations of the trucking business. These companies are often responsible for booking jobs, assigning routes, hiring and supervising drivers, and truck maintenance. Since, again, employers are responsible for the actions of their employees, a management company will typically be liable for any accidents that are caused by one of their drivers. The scope of the management company’s duties will often determine the extent to which they are liable in comparison to other defendants. The greater the scope of their authority, the greater the extent to which a management company will likely be liable.

Other third-parties may face potential liability

(back to contents)

There are situations where additional third-parties may face liability for a trucking accident even if they are not involved in the ownership or operation of the semi. Examples of such defendants may include a company which loaded cargo onto a truck but did so in a negligent way that made the vehicle unstable on the road. Third-party maintenance providers may also face liability in some instances. A variety of factors, unique to each individual case, will determine whether a third-party may possibly be named in a lawsuit.

Calculating damages in a DFW truck accident case

(back to contents)

make making financial determinationsWhen calculating a truck accident victim’s damages, multiple components are considered. First, a victim will be entitled to “compensatory” damages. These are further subdivided into “economic” and “non-economic” amounts. Second, and while somewhat rare, a victim may be entitled to punitive damages. While compensatory damages are meant to “compensate” the victim for harm they have suffered, punitive damages are meant to “punish” a defendant for harm that they have inflicted. Third, any monetary award will be subject to a potential reduction under Texas’ comparative fault laws. Finally, it is important to understand how Texas’ laws on joint and several liability apply to these types of matters, as they can affect your ability to collect a judgment. This section of our guide will discuss each of these issues in turn.

A truck accident victim may be entitled to compensatory damages

(back to contents)

Trucking accident victims in the DFW area, and elsewhere in Texas, can be entitled to compensation for their economic and non-economic losses. A victim’s economic losses are those which involve money coming out-of-pocket or those which prevented money from going into one’s pocket. Examples of such damages include past and future medical expenses, past and future lost wages, and other money which has or will be lost as a result of the case. An example of these additional monies may include transportation costs associated with getting to and from medical appointments. If one has been severely injured, and can no longer care for their children, then the cost of a live-in nanny may be appropriate. The amount which one has lost in any given case will depend on the facts of the matter.

A victim can also be compensated for their non-economic losses. Non-economic losses are often referred to as “pain and suffering.” This is the amount that one may receive for the physical pain, emotional anguish, frustration, inconvenience, and loss in quality of life that has been endured. Given that truck accident cases can involve serious injuries (including brain trauma, spinal damage, etc.), the amount of pain and suffering one may endure may be extreme. Finally, family members may also be eligible for compensation if their life has been impacted, in that the quality of their companionship with the victim has been affected.  While economic losses are often quantifiable, the determination of pain and suffering can be far more subjective.

Punitive damages will rarely (but sometimes) be awarded in a trucking accident case

(back to contents)

If the defendant or defendants have engaged in gross negligence, then punitive damages (also known as “exemplary damages”) may be appropriate. Such damages are meant to “punish” a wrongdoer so as to discourage such conduct by them or others in the future. The key to obtaining such damages is, again, that the conduct must have been beyond ordinary negligence. Negligent conduct, even if intentional, will often not be enough to warrant a punitive damages award. For example, if a truck driver was intentionally going ten miles an hour over the speed limit to make a deadline and an accident results, punitive damages would likely not be awarded. If, however, it is shown that the truck driver was high on drugs and that the owner of the vehicle had foregone drug testing due to a shortage of drivers, then a punitive award may be possible. Again, each case will depend on the facts of the matter.

Punitive damages in the state of Texas are subject to statutory caps. If punitive damages are found to be appropriate, then a victim may receive the greater of $200,000 or twice their economic damages plus their non-economic damages, subject to a cap of $750,000[1].

Texas’ comparative fault laws will apply to trucking accidents in Fort Worth and elsewhere

(back to contents)

Texas is a comparative fault state. This means that a victim may recover damages even if they were partially at fault for the accident. If the victim was found to be partially at fault for the wreck, then any damages awarded will be reduced by a percentage that is equal to the victim’s percentage of blame (punitive damages will not be subject to this reduction). These allocations of fault are determined by the jury, and if a victim is found to be fifty-one percent or more responsible for the accident, then they will be prohibited from recovering damages. As with the determination of damages themselves, the determination as to how much fault each party bears is a decision that is left to the jury.

The applicability of comparative fault can best be explained through an example of Joe Driver. Suppose Joe is driving on a Fort Worth residential street and he comes to a four-way stop. Joe is looking at his phone while driving and does not come to a full stop before proceeding into the intersection. Had he been paying attention, he would have realized that a semi-truck was barreling in his direction in one of the other lanes and that the truck was unlikely to stop. The truck runs the stop sign and hits Joe’s car. Joe suffers severe spine damage. His personal life and career are forever altered. Discovery shows that the driver of the truck had been on the road for seventeen hours even though Texas law requires him to stop driving after twelve. It is also shown that the company was aware that the driver was doctoring his logbooks to show less driving time and that the company took no action out of a desire to boost profit.

The jury awards Joe $2,000,000 in compensatory damages. Joe also receives $750,000 in punitive damages due to the company’s gross negligence of allowing the doctored driving logs. Finally, the jury finds that Joe should bear ten percent of the blame due to the fact that he likely would have seen the truck coming had he not been paying attention to his phone while driving. Under this scenario, Joe will receive $2,550,000. This includes Joe’s $2m compensatory award minus the ten percent reduction as well as the full $750,000 punitive damages award. It is always important to remember, however, that jurors are human beings and that other jurors may have looked at these same facts and reached a different conclusion. Some may have even found that Joe was more at fault for the accident than the truck driver.

How Texas’ joint and several liability standards apply in truck accident cases involving multiple defendants

(back to contents)

As explained in the section above, a jury will be charged with determining how much responsibility each party bears in a truck accident case. This also means that the jurors will be responsible for determining how much liability should be apportioned to each defendant in cases where multiple parties have been named. Texas’ laws regarding joint and several liability can greatly impact the ability of a plaintiff to recover damages when a jury allocates fault amongst several defendants. Under our state’s laws, a defendant will be responsible for a percentage of the damages award that is no greater than their share of fault for the accident. An exception to this rule is that if any one defendant is more than fifty percent responsible for the accident, then they will be jointly and severally responsible for all of the victim’s damages[2].

To illustrate how Texas’ joint and several liability system works, we will use the example of Jack. Suppose that Jack was involved in a truck accident and the jury found that he had suffered $1,000,000 in damages. Now suppose that the jury allocated forty percent of the fault to a third-party loading company that overloaded the trailer and the other sixty percent of the fault to the owner-operator of the truck. Under these facts, Jack may collect no more than $400,000 from the loading company ($1m * 40 percent), but he may collect the entire $1m from the owner-operator, who was over fifty percent responsible for the accident. When you consider that different parties may have different levels of insurance coverage, this demonstration shows why the application of joint and several liability is crucial.

An important point to note in regard to Texas’ joint and several liability laws is that they do not apply to a punitive damages award, if one is issued. Since punitive damages are meant to punish a particular defendant for their egregious conduct, responsibility for an award does not pass to others. If a jury were to decide that multiple parties engaged in a scheme of misconduct, which amounted to gross negligence, then a punitive damages amount, specific to each defendant, would be awarded.

To illustrate how a punitive damages award would escape joint and several liability, we will continue with Jack’s example from above. Suppose the jury found that $200,000 in punitive damages was appropriate due to gross negligence on the part of all defendants. This number would be specifically allocated between the two. For example, the owner-operator may be allocated $120,000 of the punitive damages. Even though this is more than half of the award, they would not be liable for the other $80,000 in punitive damages allocated to the loading company.

The stages of handling personal injury claims stemming from truck accidents in Fort Worth and other Texas areas

(back to contents)

It can take multiple years to fully resolve injury claims that stem from truck accidents. The amount of time it takes to resolve a matter will be determined by how long it takes to reasonably understand the extent of a victim’s damages, the extent to which liability or damages are disputed, as well as other factors. In this section of our guide, we will discuss what may be referred to as the “treatment” phase of such cases, the “negotiation” phase, and the litigation process.

Truck accident cases will largely be in a “holding pattern” while the victim treats for their injuries and may take some time to settle

(back to contents)

medical rehabAccident victims are often immediately contacted by insurance carriers who wish to attempt to negotiate with them directly. In some instances they may even make contact with the victim on the day of the accident. This is also true for incidents involving a semi-truck. These carriers will often claim that it is best for a victim to negotiate with them directly and that the victim “does not need an attorney.” It must be remembered, however, that these adjusters are employees of the insurance company. It is their job to settle the case for as little money as possible, and it is not their role to ensure that the victim’s rights are protected. A personal injury attorney, by contrast, is charged with the role of ensuring that a victim is gaining the highest possible compensation. For these reasons, it is generally advisable that one speak with and retain counsel rather than dealing with the insurance carriers directly.

A truck accident victim’s injury attorney will immediately contact the defendant(s) once they have been retained. The defendants will typically forward the notice of representation to their insurance carrier. The victim’s counsel will then deal with the insurance carriers directly. At this stage of the case, the victim is treating their injuries with the necessary medical professionals. This treatment can take several months, or more than a year in cases that involve serious harm and require multiple surgeries. Also, during this time, the victim’s attorney will conduct a full investigation into the matter. This can involve researching possible defendants, interviewing witnesses, obtaining police reports, and more. How much time a victim must spend treating their injuries, and what is necessary to conduct a full investigation, will always depend on the facts of the matter.

It is common for those who have been harmed to ask, “How long does it take to settle a truck accident case?” This is understandable as many wish to get the matter behind them and move on with their lives. With that said, it is generally advisable that one not settle until they have as much information as possible about the extent to which they will recover from their injuries. If a victim were to accept a “quick” settlement and not recover to the extent that they expected to, then they may be without money that is needed in the future for medical bills or to pay living expenses. One’s attorney will always give them an honest assessment as to whether accepting a settlement may be premature.

To underscore the importance of not settling prematurely, we will give the example of Bill. After his car was hit by a semi-truck, Bill was diagnosed with a brain injury. His symptoms included dizziness and a lack of coordination. He was told by his treating physician that, more than fifty percent of the time, victims make a full recovery within one to two years and that no type of surgery is required. Bill believes that he will be in this majority and that he will be able to return to his job as a construction worker within one to two years. Bill accepts a $250,000 settlement so that he may move on with his life. Unfortunately, Bill does not recover, and he is not able to return to his former profession. Bill is only thirty years old, and his lifetime lost earnings are well over $1,000,000. He will also need money for future medical care. Unfortunately, since Bill has settled his case, he is not able to seek additional compensation. Had Bill waited to find out if he, in fact, was going to recover, then he would have been able to pursue a higher compensation amount. This simplified example shows the potential problem with settling a case too soon for the sole purpose of getting it over with.

The negotiation phase of a case will begin with the sending of a demand letter

(back to contents)

Once a victim’s damages can be reasonably understood (to the extent possible), then their attorney will send a demand letter (a request for payment) to the applicable insurance carriers. This demand will state the amount that the victim is requesting, a breakdown of how that amount was calculated, and documentation supporting the claim. This documentation may include incident reports, medical records, pay stubs, tax returns, etc. Once the carrier receives the demand letter, they will either attempt to deny liability outright or begin negotiating with the victim’s lawyer. If the carriers do not deny liability outright, then negotiations often revolve around the amount of a victim’s damages or whether the carrier believes comparative fault is an issue. During this time, the insurers may request additional information or may ask to conduct an Independent Medical Examination (IME) of the victim. If the parties can agree on a settlement amount, then the case will be resolved. If a settlement cannot be reached, then litigation will become necessary.

It is sometimes necessary to file a lawsuit while the parties are still negotiating in good faith. This can be for multiple reasons. First, if the Plaintiff has had a lengthy treatment period, then it may be necessary to file a case to prevent the statute of limitations (which is typically two years) from running. The parties may then continue to negotiate after the case is filed. Second, if it is clear that there are additional defendants who have not yet been identified, then a lawsuit may be filed that names “fictitious defendants.” This allows for protecting the statute of limitations against such parties. While the filing of a lawsuit typically means that negotiations have failed, these are two instances in which it does not necessarily mean the end of the case’s negotiation phase.

One additional point to note, with regard to negotiations, is that the victim’s attorney will inform them of all settlement offers made by the defense. We say this due to the fact that the victim should be prepared for the insurer to make an excessively low offer. This is a standard negotiating tactic used by insurance companies. One’s attorney will expect a low opening offer and not be fazed by it. Quite often, however, this tactic has the effect of worrying the victim about the viability of their case. Again, a low initial offer does not mean that the insurance company actually expects the case to settle at that amount. Counsel will take steps to ensure that their client is aware of this.

The litigation phase of a truck accident case

(back to contents)

courtroom trialIf a settlement is not reached during the negotiation phase of the case (described above), then it will be necessary for the victim’s attorney to proceed with a lawsuit. Once the case has been filed, each of the defendants will file an initial response, and discovery (the process by which information is gained from the other side) will begin shortly thereafter. Each side is provided with several tools which can be used to obtain information. These include Interrogatories, which require another party to provide written answers to written questions. Other tools include Requests for Production, which can be used to obtain records or tangible objects. Also, Depositions may be used to take sworn testimony from witnesses. A Plaintiff’s discovery will typically involve requesting documents meant to obtain information which can be used to establish liability. The defendants will typically attempt to obtain information that establishes that the victim was at fault, as well as information that disproves their damages claim.

Discovery can go on for some time in a truck accident case. Depending on the facts of the claim, the victim’s counsel may need to review years worth of driving records and work records to establish that there has been an ongoing pattern of misconduct and public endangerment. Also, the process in and of itself can be time-consuming, as each side is given a period of time to offer responses to discovery requests. While clients sometimes are frustrated with the slow nature of the legal process, it is, unfortunately, how the system works, and one should be prepared for discovery to take many months, if not over a year.

Each side will often designate expert witnesses during the discovery process. Experts are often necessary in trucking accident cases as laypeople are not permitted to offer testimony about facts that require specialized knowledge or skill. Typical experts in such cases can include accident reconstructionists, who review all available information about the crash and offer an opinion as to how the wreck occurred. Experts on the trucking industry may also be required to offer an opinion as to whether the truck driver, or his employer, was following proper safety precautions. Other necessary experts may include medical professionals who will offer an opinion as to the extent, if any, the victim is expected to recover. Vocational and economic experts will also likely be required to offer opinions as to how the victim’s future earnings have been impacted.

An important point to note is that settlement negotiations will often be continuing while discovery is being conducted and expert witnesses are being designated and deposed. These negotiations will take place between the victim’s injury lawyer and the attorneys for the insurance carriers. In some instances, the two sides may attend a non-binding mediation. This is a negotiating environment in which a neutral third-party, the mediator, attempts to broker a deal between the two sides. If no settlement is reached through direct negotiations, or at a mediation, then the case will proceed to trial.

The trial process will begin with the selection of a jury. The lawyers for each side will ask questions of individuals who comprise a pool of potential jurors. This pool is drawn from residents of the county in which the lawsuit is filed. So, if the case is filed in Tarrant County, then Tarrant County residents would make up the jury pool. Once the jury has been seated, then each side will make an opening statement. Opening statements are not a time for argument. Instead, counsel for each side may only use them to inform the jury of the evidence which they can expect to hear and to state the relief that is being requested.

The Plaintiff (the victim) will begin by presenting their evidence and witnesses. The defendant (s) will then present their case. The Plaintiff will then be permitted to proceed with “rebuttal” evidence. New facts or arguments may not be raised on rebuttal. Instead, this portion of the case may only be used to directly address facts which have been raised by the defense. Once rebuttal has been concluded, then each side will make a closing argument. The jurors will receive a set of instructions from the Court and will begin their deliberations. A verdict will be returned on the issue of liability, comparative fault (if applicable), and damages. If punitive damages are at issue, then a second stage of the trial will be held solely on that issue. This will conclude the trial process.

Selecting a lawyer for truck accident cases in Fort Worth or other parts of Texas

(back to contents)

The choice of a personal injury attorney is very important for truck accident victims in Fort Worth and other Texas areas. These types of matters can become quite complex, and it is common for one’s lawyer to pay substantial expenses up front. A victim’s attorney will not recoup these up front costs unless they prevail at trial or the matter settles. Examples of such expenses can include the costs associated with expert witnesses and other discovery efforts, which are described above. Depending on the facts of the case, these costs can be in the hundreds of thousands of dollars. Retaining an attorney without the resources necessary to see this process through to the end can mean that a victim may not have needed evidence at trial.

Factors to consider when selecting counsel to assist you include the level of financial resources they have available for the reasons described above. Other factors to consider are whether the firm employs multiple attorneys, as such matters can quickly become time-consuming. Also, one may wish to consider whether the attorneys with whom they are consulting are Board Certified and what steps the firm will take to investigate the facts of the case.

Contact Noteboom – The Law Firm to speak with a Fort Worth truck accident lawyer

If you or a loved one have been hit by an 18-wheeler, then contact Noteboom – The Law Firm to speak with a Fort Worth truck accident lawyer. We have been serving the area for decades, and we believe in standing up for the rights of people over those of companies. Chuck Noteboom and Brian Butcher are both Board Certified in Personal Injury Trial Law by the Texas Board of Legal Specialization, and we employ an on-staff investigator. Our firm has the resources necessary to litigate against large defendants, and our firm will give your matter the attention it deserves. Contact us online or by telephone to schedule an initial consultation. We look forward to speaking with you.

In addition to Texas’ greater DFW area, we also handle matters in Arlington, Austin, Denton, Frisco, Irving, Lufkin, Garland, Houston, McKinney, Richardson, San Antonio, and the rest of the state.

Contact Us

Disclaimer

This guide is provided for general informational purposes only. It is not legal advice; it does not address the facts of any particular case, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship with Noteboom – The Law Firm. The individuals and dollar figures used in the examples above are hypothetical and are not representative of any actual case or result. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

References

[1] CIVIL PRACTICE AND REMEDIES CODE CHAPTER 41.008(b)

[2] CIVIL PRACTICE AND REMEDIES CODE CHAPTER 33.013(b)

Contact Us